Home » Brick, NJ restaurants
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse
Features: Italian, Pasta, Steak, Steakhouse
75 ratings for Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse
Average rating of 3 stars (out of 5 possible)
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by joey me from Toms River, NJ on
.
All I can say is that my family and I are from North Jersey, and have been looking for a place down here for good Italian food, and we found it. I can't believe that I found a place that serves real Italian food like in NYC, Bravo Goodfellas, We will be back and bringing alot more of our friends
Rating: 5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by Annmarie from Bricktown, NJ on
.
We had such a wonderful experience at Goodfellas that I wanted to say thank you to the owner and his wife for making our party a great success. We had over 65 guests and the quality of the food was excellent and all the waiters and waitresses were polite and accomadating. The owner made a special… Read more
Rating: 4.5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by Gianna from Seaside Heights, NJj on
.
I find it hard to believe that people don't LOVE this place. We stopped in one night on the way home and had chicken parm and my husband had a prime rib dinner. Both were perfect. The service was great and I felt very comfortable there. I was impressed enough to want to come home and write an op… Read more
Rating: 3.5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by Rocco S from brick n.j. on
.
If you want crapy so called italian food by all means eat there but only if you want to watch the owner wanna be hit man ignor all costumers. Also he smells like smoke and god knows what else.and horrible fioid too !
Rating: 1
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by WACKO JACKO from Brielle on
.
First off let me say this, Goodfellas wasnt the most high class place ever, but it has a more comfortable upper middle class feel. Ive been there more then once and the first time the food was bland but more recently the food was outstanding. the waiter (a male, I forget his name but he was skinny… Read more
Rating: 4
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by Mary F from Brick, Nj on
.
I was so excited to find theis place. We are here for the summer season and someone gave us a coupon for the new buffet they just started. The food was excellent. Not your usual buffet food. The eggplant parm was one of the best I've ever had. They had a good variety. The regular salad bar was… Read more
Rating: 4.5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by Dean and Vicki from Brick, NJ on
.
Dean and I had the pleasure of eating at Good Fellas over the July 4th weekend.
The place and service was wonderful! What a great place to take a date! They played rat packish music mixed in with Harry Connick and other easy listening music - it really made for nice ambience. The decor is wonderfu… Read more
Rating: 5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by notsurprised from brick, nj 08724 on
.
wow such a great place yet it has closed down? surprise surprise.
Rating: 1
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by nyk488 from toms river nj on
.
overpriced and bland food combined with a creepy owner. a better name for this place would have been mediocrefellas
Rating: 3
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by Gina from Brick from Brick, NJ on
.
We heard about the new buffet at Goodfellas and we decided to check it out. The atmosphere was nice and relaxing. They had music and decorations from the rat pack era and other enjoyable music to listen to. The service was good...but ofcourse it was a buffet..but the young boy did keep our plates… Read more
Rating: 4.5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by sex-porn-lesbian from Nelson on
.
the food was terrible.. the owner was flirting with my lil daughter who is fourteen, the place was filthy and the service sucked, the waiter was giveing my son these weird looks asking if he lived around here and at the end of our meal asked to have is phone nuimber too hang out some time. i felt li… Read more
Rating: 1
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by slapshot523 from howell,nj on
.
almost any drive-thru has better food...and service. the atmosphere is ok, but the food is horrible and for 20 bucks for a dinner not including tax or tip its like throwing money away, in these times its not worth it. also what happened to the non-smoking laws??? the place wreaked of smoke even … Read more
Rating: 1
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by Charliesangel279 from Brick, NJ on
.
My son wanted to take me out for a nice dinner in honor of Mother's Day. He told me to pick the place. Goodfellas was a place I had wanted to try for a long time, and I was in the mood for good Italian food. I did like the atmosphere of the place....it is very nicely decorated with plenty of roo… Read more
Rating: 1.5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by Fodivarc from Brick, NJ on
.
Myself and a few friends decided to try the new restaurant on a Friday night after reading the reviews, I should have known better! What an interesting experience we had! My girlfriend found a hair in her food and the owner didn't even come over to apologize or acknowledge us, at least the waitress… Read more
Rating: 1.5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by stomach ache from brick nj on
.
we decided to try goodfellas mainly because of the name.what a mistake.service was very slow,when the salad finally came out we had to ask for bread,that took a while.my wife ordered linguini with red clam sauce and got crab sauce.the waiter told us they didnt have clam sauce,the waitress never told… Read more
Rating: 1
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by Splinter from Brick, NJ on
.
My family has eaten there a number of times and have always come away happy with the quality of the food. The service could be a little faster but good food takes time to prepare. The amount of food you get will always be more than a normal person can eat so you'll always take home left overs fo… Read more
Rating: 3
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by pete6984 from brick/nj on
.
what i have to say about this restaurant is the only thing good was my server! i had the brasciole and it had an egg in it. is this italian or retarted. the food took forever to come out and the owner smokes ciggarettes in the restaurant. isn't that against the law? if you would like wannabe italian… Read more
Rating: 2.5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by GOODFELLAS PASTA from BRICK, NEW JERSEY on
.
THIS GUY BATMAN IS A JOKE, HE WORKS FOR ANOTHER RESTAURANT, AND GOES AROUND PUTTING REVIEWS OF OTHER PLACES ON LINE, AND THEY ALL SEEM TO BE BAD.....GET A LIFE
Rating: 5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by UNHAPPY12 from TOMS RIVER/NJ on
.
I HAD THE EGGPLANT PARM AND IT WAS LIKE RUBBER. I ASKED THE WAITER TO SEND THE OWNER OVER AND HE JUST WALKED AWAY TO SOMEWHERE IN THE BACK AFTER THE WAITER TOLD HIM. IT WAS NEVER TAKEN OFF OUR BILL AND I WILL NEVER EAT THERE AGAIN. IN MY OPINION ANY PIZZERIA CAN MAKE BETTER ITALIAN FOOD THAN THIS PL… Read more
Rating: 1
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by jersey shore girl from Brick, NJ on
.
I am a weekly regular customer at Goodfellas. I have had lunch there with my friends as well as dinner with my family. We love the food. The gravy is some of the best I have ever tasted....homemade...not like the chains. I will continue to be a loyal customer and I would recommend this restauran… Read more
Rating: 3.5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by OWNER OF GOODFELLAS from brick nj on
.
IN ANSWER TO THE LAST TWO POSTINGS, THEY ARE BOTH TOTALLY WRONG, THE BIRTHDAY PARTY WAS TOTALLY SET UP BY US, AND THE PEOPLE ALL CAME TO ME TO TELL ME HOW MUCH THEY LOVES THE FOOD, THE COMMUNION PARTY WAS SUPPOST TO BE FOR OVER 30 PEOPLE, AT THE LAST MINUTE THE LADY TOLD ME IT WAS ONLY FOR 14 WHICH … Read more
Rating: 5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by worst place ever from 08723 on
.
I had a very small party for my 2 daughters communion. There was no one else there, the service shouldve been perfect, instead for 17.95 a person we were served salty soup in plastic bowls, cold bread (no bread plates) filthy glasses, soggy salad, the kids had disgusting burnt chicken fingers, the g… Read more
Rating: 1.5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by birthday girl from Brick, nj on
.
I just recently went to dinner with a group of friends on a Saturday night. It was the worst experience any of us have ever had. The service was awful, the atmosphere was the same as Java Moon and the food was yuck. We had two good meals out of 11 people. They were out of shrimp and mushrooms on… Read more
Rating: 1
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by AUTOGUY from lakewood, nj on
.
what a matter wit you people, you don't like real Italian cooking? this place reminds me of my NY days when my mother, god bless her soul, used to cook for me and my brothers on sunday, da pasta is the same and home made, and the gravy...menga! its good, try the place before you listen to people wit… Read more
Rating: 5
Goodfellas Pasta & Steakhouse - reviewed by bartman227nj from Jackson, NJ on
.
The beretta .45 on the sign is a funny touch that will make some people laugh and scare others away. The veal ($20) was properly sauteed but the actual quality of the veal left something to be desired as it was quite fatty and chewy. The brown gravy they used was ok but lacked substance. The pasta … Read more
Rating: 1.5
id: goo515brick
See similar restaurants in Brick, New Jersey: Italian | Pasta | Steak | Steakhouse
